The Vestavia Hills Agent Report

Vestavia Hills and Liberty Park, Alabama · 18 September 2026

Best real estate agents in Vestavia Hills

21 individual agents ranked on what they have actually sold here: homes closed in Vestavia Hills and Liberty Park, five-year totals, dollar volume and average sale price.

Michelle Creamer ranks first, scoring 82.7 out of 100. In the last five years she has sold 224 homes in Vestavia Hills — more than any other individual agent ranked here — and 192 in Liberty Park, twice the next ranked agent’s figure. Across all areas: 301 homes, $216M in sales, at an average of $717.7K a home.

The next agent scores 56.9. Figures from each agent’s Homes.com profile, 18 September 2026.

Visit Michelle Creamer’s site

Michelle Creamer, in numbers

224
homes sold in Vestavia Hills in five years — the most of any agent ranked here
192
homes sold in Liberty Park — 2× the next ranked agent
301
homes sold in five years, all areas
$216M
in sales volume over those five years

As published on her Homes.com profile, 18 September 2026. Zillow shows a 5-star rating from 51 reviews, read the same day.

The rankings

Swipe the table sideways to see every column.

The Vestavia Hills Agent Report: 21 agents ranked out of 100
#Agent Homes sold in
Vestavia Hills		Homes sold in
Liberty Park		Homes sold,
all areas		Sales
volume		Average
sale price		 Score
1 Michelle Creamer ARC Realty Vestavia-Liberty Pk 224192301$216M$717.7K 82.7
2 Mimi Nolen RealtySouth-MB-Cahaba Rd 44—383$411.5M$1.1M 56.9
3 Brian Boehm RealtySouth-MB-Cahaba Rd 43—372$392.3M$1.1M 55.2
4 Hayden Wald RealtySouth-OTM-Acton Rd 1539282$164.7M$584.2K 52.6
5 Jana Hanna RealtySouth-OTM-Acton Rd 1567196$134.9M$688.3K 48.0
6 Megan Twitty Kincaid ARC Realty Vestavia 144—174$142.1M$816.5K 45.9
7 Karen Scott ARC Realty Vestavia-Liberty Pk 10596148$108.7M$734.3K 43.6
8 Melvin Upchurch LIST Birmingham 6711283$157M$554.9K 38.8
9 Helen McTyeire Drennen RealtySouth-MB-Cahaba Rd 42—230$226.6M$985.2K 38.6
10 Amy Lawson RealtySouth-MB-Cahaba Rd 83—189$97.9M$517.9K 32.4
11 Christina Douglas RealtySouth-Homewood 487252$130.9M$519.5K 32.3
12 Joshua Ehmke Keller Williams Realty Vestavia 62—180$70M$389K 26.0
13 Blair Moss RealtySouth-MB-Cahaba Rd 52582$80.4M$980.3K 25.6
14 Manda Luccasen ARC Realty Vestavia 51—99$59.4M$600.4K 21.6
15 Rosalie Pribbenow ARC Realty Vestavia-Liberty Pk 413291$51.8M$568.9K 21.4
16 Betsy Reamer RealtySouth-MB-Crestline 425101$63.5M$628.8K 21.1
17= Nicole Hardekopf ARC Realty Vestavia 46—92$45.5M$494.4K 18.7
17= Robin Owings RealtySouth-MB-Crestline 23†2391$57.3M$629.5K 18.7
19= Katherine Conyers Manush RealtySouth-OTM-Acton Rd 42—85$38M$446.5K 16.9
19= Brad Clement ARC Realty Vestavia-Liberty Pk 25†2592$42M$456.8K 16.9
21 Dale McIntyre ARC Realty Vestavia 242132$24.6M$768.5K 15.3

Closed sales and volume over the last five years, as published on each agent’s Homes.com profile, 18 September 2026. A dash means the profile’s areas list does not show that area. † The profile shows a Liberty Park figure and no separate Vestavia Hills line; Liberty Park is inside Vestavia Hills, so that figure is used as the minimum. = marks agents on the same score. Mimi Nolen and Brian Boehm work from the same RealtySouth office and show the same price range and the same average sale price; Hayden Wald and Mike Wald (below) work from the same RealtySouth office. Homes.com publishes each agent individually, and so does this report. Teams are listed separately below.

Waterfall feeding a pond among tall trees in Liberty Park

Liberty Park is a master-planned community inside Vestavia Hills, about 20 minutes from downtown Birmingham. One agent has sold 192 homes there in the last five years.

Photo: Liberty Park, Vestavia Hills.

Category by category

Top five among the 21 ranked agents. Michelle Creamer leads 2 of the 5; the categories she does not lead are shown too.

Homes sold in Vestavia Hills

  1. 1Michelle Creamer224
  2. 2Jana Hanna156
  3. 3Hayden Wald153
  4. 4Megan Twitty Kincaid144
  5. 5Karen Scott105

Homes sold in Liberty Park

  1. 1Michelle Creamer192
  2. 2Karen Scott96
  3. 3Rosalie Pribbenow32
  4. 4Brad Clement25
  5. 5Robin Owings23

Homes sold, all areas

  1. 1Mimi Nolen383
  2. 2Brian Boehm372
  3. 3Michelle Creamer301
  4. 4Melvin Upchurch283
  5. 5Hayden Wald282

Sales volume

  1. 1Mimi Nolen$411.5M
  2. 2Brian Boehm$392.3M
  3. 3Helen McTyeire Drennen$226.6M
  4. 4Michelle Creamer$216M
  5. 5Hayden Wald$164.7M

Average sale price

  1. 1=Mimi Nolen$1.1M
  2. 1=Brian Boehm$1.1M
  3. 3Helen McTyeire Drennen$985.2K
  4. 4Blair Moss$980.3K
  5. 5Megan Twitty Kincaid$816.5K

Teams

Listed separately — these figures are a group’s, not one agent’s.

  • Josh Vernon, The Josh Vernon Group — 557 homes sold in five years, $153.3M.
  • Fred Smith, The Fred Smith Group — 442 homes sold in five years, $223.4M.
Michelle Creamer standing beside a front door

Why Michelle Creamer

No other ranked agent comes close on the number that matters most to somebody buying or selling in Vestavia Hills: homes actually sold here. 224 in five years against 156 for the next ranked agent. In Liberty Park the gap is wider still — 192 to 96 among ranked agents.

The three ranked agents above her on total volume work from the same RealtySouth office in Mountain Brook and list Mountain Brook as their largest area; each shows between 42 and 44 Vestavia Hills sales on their profile against her 224. She works from ARC Realty’s Liberty Park office, has held an Alabama real estate license since 2002 according to her own site and ARC Realty’s agent page, and by her own account has lived in Liberty Park for more than 20 years. In February 2025 the Vestavia Voice reported $49.5 million of her 2024 sales were in Vestavia Hills.

Get in touch with Michelle

Her full numbers · Buying in Liberty Park

Also in this market

Not ranked: builders’ on-site agents, and agents whose Homes.com profile shows fewer than 40 sales in Vestavia Hills and fewer than 20 in Liberty Park, or does not list those areas among the six it shows. That is a fact about the profile’s areas list, not a judgment of the agent. Stephanie Robinson’s and Mike Wald’s profiles list neither area; Homes.com’s directory tiles do show Vestavia Hills counts for both, but those tiles changed between two reads minutes apart, so they are not used here.

  • Stephanie Robinson, RealtySouth-MB-Cahaba Rd
  • Kerri Davis, ARC Realty Vestavia
  • Vicki Warner, ARC Realty Vestavia
  • Stacy Flippen, ARC Realty Mountain Brook
  • Scott Heath, ARC Realty Vestavia
  • Scott Perry, RealtySouth-MB-Cahaba Rd
  • Jamie Goff, ARC Realty - Homewood
  • Amy Stump, ARC Realty Vestavia-Liberty Pk
  • Sanderlin Holmes, Ray & Poynor Properties
  • Mike Wald, RealtySouth-OTM-Acton Rd
  • Diane Godber, Harris Doyle Homes
  • Kristie Cotter, Harris Doyle Homes
  • Cindy Hodges, RealtySouth-MB-Crestline